In order for publications to be eligible for submission to Research Excellence Framework (REF) 2021 the following conditions must be met:
The authors’ final peer-reviewed manuscripts (Author’s Accepted Manuscripts) must be deposited in an institutional/subject repository (such as STORRE) within 3 months of acceptance for publication.
Deposited material should be discoverable and free to read and download
The policy allows authors to respect embargo periods set by publishers of: up to 12 months for Main Panels A and B; or 24 months for Main Panels C and D (Social sciences, Arts & Humanities). If you publish in a journal with a longer embargo a policy exception may be applied – see: What if my output doesn’t comply below.
The requirement applies to journal articles (including systematic reviews) and papers from conference proceedings*.
The policy does not apply to monographs, book chapters, other long-form publications, working papers, creative or practice-based research outputs, or data.
The policy applies to research outputs accepted for publication after 1 April 2016.
*Note: The proceedings requirement applies to papers from conference proceedings with an International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) or conference papers published in journals with an ISBN or conferences papers that are published online-only in journal-like series of proceedings (typically in the sciences). If in doubt assume your conference paper needs to comply. Details at: http://www.hefce.ac.uk/rsrch/oa/faq/#other in Section 2.4.
There is a two-page summary in Box of these decisions for Stirling staff, covering various aspects of the exercise including staff eligibility, and the number of outputs and impact case studies required.
Complying with the REF OA Policy
To comply with the REF policy, Stirling researchers should submit their publication details to Worktribe and attach the full-text PDF file of their final peer-reviewed manuscripts. The PDF file will be copied to STORRE, the University's institutional repository.
Date of Acceptance and required version of publication
The date of acceptance is the point at which the author is notified that:
their output has been reviewed by the journal or conference (normally via peer review)
all academically necessary changes have been made in response to that review
the article is ready to be taken through the final steps toward publication (normally copy-editing and typesetting).
By this point, the paper should have been updated to include all changes resulting from peer review as well as any changes of an academic nature requested by the journal editor or conference organiser. At this stage, the journal editor or conference organiser normally notifies the author that their paper has been ‘firmly’ accepted (as opposed to any earlier point of ‘provisional’ acceptance e.g. conditional on major or minor revisions being made) and the paper is ready for copy-editing or typesetting; it is the date of this notification that should be taken to mean the date of acceptance.
The author’s final, accepted manuscript is the one that has been agreed with the editor at that point. The accepted manuscript is not the same as the copy-edited, typeset or published paper – these versions are known as ‘proofs’ or ‘versions of record’ and publishers do not normally allow authors to make these open-access.
Note that making your publication available via social networking sites such as ResearchGate or Academia.edu will not meet the REF Open Access requirement. A social networking site is not an open access repository and there are major differences between such networking sites and Open Access institutional/subject repositories (such as STORRE).
What if my output doesn't comply?
There may be occasions when an item cannot meet the Open Access requirements outlined above. In these cases an exception must be noted for the output to be REF eligible.
If you know you will not be able to deposit your accepted manuscript in Worktribe (for STORRE) within the appropriate timescale (as soon after the point of acceptance as possible, and no later than three months after this date), contact the Repository Librarian as soon as possible.
If you know your accepted manuscript is later than the 3 months Deposit requirement, you will need to enter your reason in the Notes field that appears in Worktribe when you are adding details/depositing your publication (use the Notes field in the Details tab or when you attach your file). Examples or reasons for non-compliance could be: you were not employed on a Category A eligible contract at another UK HEI at the time of submission for publication or there was a delay in securing the final peer-reviewed text (for instance, where a paper has multiple authors).
If after the 3 months has elapsed it is possible to deposit your publication file you should go ahead and do this. You can request a change to the Worktribe record so that you can attach the file – see the Worktribe guide at: https://stir.box.com/s/cjcmqpopcftodsk07tx4db6g6ipv6a6i
Not all publications allow a repository to make the accepted manuscript available. Some may offer embargo periods that are longer than the 12/24 months permitted by the REF policy. In these cases, you can cite an exception if you can justify that the publication was the most appropriate place for the output. HEFCE is looking for evidence that authors are aware of the OA requirements and have made best efforts to make their work OA.
You should consider the embargo length a publication requires before committing to publish there, and consider if there is a viable alternative that does offer a compliant embargo period. If the publication does not have any information at all on open access the Library and Archives Research Support team would be happy to work with you to approach the journal and negotiate an embargo period, contact the: Repository Librarian.
If you know your publication does not have a compliant embargo period, you will need to give your evidence that this publication was the most appropriate; enter your explanation in the Notes field that appears when you attach your file when depositing your work in Worktribe. (You should still deposit your work in Worktribe (for STORRE) within 3 months of acceptance).
“I have considered submitting this article to a number of journals. Given its prominence in the field of X [and/or] the journal’s readership, journal Y is the most appropriate one for the output.”
“I am aware of the Open Access requirements for the REF and take them into account when considering publishing venues. Ideally I would publish in a venue with no embargo or a shorter embargo that complies with the REF requirements. Unfortunately on this occasion the most appropriate journal (that would accept my submission) did not comply with the Access requirements.”