Research Report
Social Values Assessment Report: Balmacara Estate
Jones S & Robson E (2026) Social Values Assessment Report: Balmacara Estate. National Trust for Scotland. University of Stirling. https://doi.org/10.34722/cbt0-4z26
Postdoctoral Research Fellow
History History, Heritage, and Politics Pathfoot Building University of Stirling FK9 4LA
BACKGROUND: I am an inter-disciplinary researcher with a professional background working internationally in community development. My research interests include: collaborative knowledge production; people-centred methods; and participatory heritage management, placemaking, and planning processes.
I received my PhD in 2021 from the division of History, Heritage and Politics at the University of Stirling. My doctoral research, in collaboration with Historic Environment Scotland, focused on qualitative methods for assessing the contemporary social values associated with the historic environment. My academic background is in History (BA, University of Exeter), Environment, Development and Policy (MA, University of Sussex), and Social Anthropology (MRes, University of Aberdeen).
Following completion of my PhD, I worked on both national and international research projects, most recently as a Postdoctoral Research Associate on the AHRC-funded Place-Based Research Programme (based in Urban Studies at University of Glasgow), which is exploring the ways that research in arts and humanities disciplines contributes to place-based agendas.
I rejoined the University of Stirling in August 2023 as Postdoctoral Research Fellow on a collaborative project with the National Trust for Scotland (NTS) titled 'Social values of NTS heritage places: towards an organisational approach'. This three-year project (2023-2026) will further develop our understanding of how the multiple and complex knowledges that social values assessments reveal can be applied within organisational policies and practices. See: https://embeddingsocialvalue.stir.ac.uk/.
RESEARCH: I am interested in the contemporary significance of what might be broadly termed historic places, although by no means limited to formally designated heritage, and the impact they have on society. I have a particular focus on understanding how participatory methods and collaborative approaches operate in both research and place management processes.
My doctoral research involved trialling a range of rapid, qualitative, and participatory methods to assess and evidence the social values associated with the historic environment - including people's sense of belonging, identity, or place. The methods were trialled across seven case study sites, ranging from Iron Age monuments to inner-city laneways. In addition to my academic thesis, I translated my findings on applying these methods in different contexts into a toolkit of practical guidance for heritage practitioners (https://socialvalue.stir.ac.uk/).
Since completing my doctorate, I have applied the methods in other projects, including as part of a European JPI-CH project called Deep Cities, which explored how evidence of historic urban transformation impacts on the values associated with modern cityscapes. As Research Assistant, I applied qualitative, participatory research methods to explore the values associated with two sites, one in Edinburgh and one in London. The overall project leader was Torgrim Guttormsen, from the Norwegian Institute for Cultural Heritage Research (NIKU), and the Stirling team was led by PI Chiara Bonacchi and Co-PI Siân Jones. Further details of the project are available here: https://curbatheri.niku.no/.
My studies have coalesced around theories of collaborative knowledge production, situated expertise, and working productively with multiplicity and complexity. My research has a strong applied focus and the collaborations with Historic Environment Scotland during my PhD and with the National Trust for Scotland in my current project provide a critical grounding in the real-world realities of heritage practice. Such collaborations enrich my academic work, as well as supporting knowledge exchange and practice-orientated outputs.
I am continuing to explore the relationships between people and place as part of the collaborative project ‘Social values of National Trust for Scotland heritage place: towards an organisational approach’ (https://embeddingsocialvalue.stir.ac.uk/). This project is led by Prof. Siân Jones and myself, as Research Fellow, working closely with colleagues from the Trust. The research has been funded by the National Trust for Scotland and the project forms part of a wider partnership between the Trust and the University of Stirling.
Saltire Emerging Researcher Award
This award, made through the Scottish Graduate School for Arts & Humanities, allowed me to spend three-months on exchange to the Department of Archaeology, Conservation and History at the University of Oslo (Norway), where I participated in the University’s ‘Heritage Experience Initiative’, a multi-disciplinary network of researchers that aims to develop critical heritage research in close co-operation with the heritage sector.
Association of Critical Heritage Studies (Member)
https://www.criticalheritagestudies.org/
Society of Antiquaries of Scotland (Fellow)
https://www.socantscot.org/
Member of the Research Environment Group
https://www.stir.ac.uk/…nce-in-research/
The University of Stirling Research Environment Group (REG) reports to the University Research Committee and has cross Faculty representation from both academic and professional service teams. It leads on development and coordination of the Concordat to Support the Career Development of Researchers action plan and the HR Excellence in Research Award.
Social values of NTS heritage places: towards an organisational approach
PI: Professor Sian Jones
Funded by: The National Trust for Scotland
–
Research Report
Social Values Assessment Report: Balmacara Estate
Jones S & Robson E (2026) Social Values Assessment Report: Balmacara Estate. National Trust for Scotland. University of Stirling. https://doi.org/10.34722/cbt0-4z26
Monograph
Assessing the Social Values of Heritage: Methods in Theory and Practice
Robson E (2025) Assessing the Social Values of Heritage: Methods in Theory and Practice. 1st edition ed. Routledge Studies in Heritage. London. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003497271
Article
Introduction: The Agency of Heritage Value(s)
Díaz de Liaño G, Pastor Pérez A, Robson E, Watson S & Barreiro Martínez D (2025) Introduction: The Agency of Heritage Value(s). Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites, 26 (5-6), pp. 359-367. https://doi.org/10.1080/13505033.2024.2516308
Article
Assessing the social values of dynamic urban heritage
Robson E, Jones S & Bonacchi C (2025) Assessing the social values of dynamic urban heritage. The Archaeologist, 125, pp. 12-14. https://doi.org/10.11588/cifatamag.2025.2.111744
Research Report
Social Values Assessment Report: Fyvie Castle, Gardens and Estate
Robson E & Jones S (2025) Social Values Assessment Report: Fyvie Castle, Gardens and Estate. National Trust for Scotland. University of Stirling. https://doi.org/10.34722/z9mc-7s63
Article
Jones S, Bonacchi C, Robson E, Broccoli E, Hiscock A, Biondi A, Nucciotti M, Guttormsen TS, Fouseki K & Díaz-Andreu M (2024) Assessing the dynamic social values of the 'deep city': an integrated methodology combining online and offline approaches. Progress in Planning, 187, Art. No.: 100852. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progress.2024.100852
Article
Bonacchi C, Jones S, Broccoli E, Hiscock A & Robson E (2023) Researching heritage values in social media environments: understanding variabilities and (in)visibilities. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 29, pp. 1021-1040. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2023.2231919
Article
Fouseki K, Hisari L, Dong X, Bonacchi C, Robson E, Broccoli E, Guttormsen TS, Nucciotti M & Shieh S (2023) Unpacking the Dynamics of Urban Transformation in Heritage Places through ‘Critical System Dynamics’: The Case of Beresford Square, Woolwich. Land, 12 (11), Art. No.: 2040. https://doi.org/10.3390/land12112040
Article
Assessing the Social Values of Built Heritage: Participatory Methods as Ways of Knowing
Robson E (2023) Assessing the Social Values of Built Heritage: Participatory Methods as Ways of Knowing. Architecture, 3 (3), pp. 428-445. https://doi.org/10.3390/architecture3030023
Dissertation
Robson E (2021) Wrestling with Social Value: An Examination of Methods and Approaches for Assessing Social Value in Heritage Management and Conservation. Doctor of Philosophy. University of Stirling. http://hdl.handle.net/1893/33355
Website Content
Robson E (2021) Social Value Toolkit. [Website] 09.06.2021. https://socialvalue.stir.ac.uk/
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Caterthuns
Robson E (2020) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Caterthuns [Site Report: The Brown and White Caterthuns, Angus]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Kinneil House and Estate
Robson E (2020) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Kinneil House and Estate [Site Report: Kinneil House and Estate, Bo'ness]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Cables Wynd House
Robson E (2020) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Cables Wynd House [Site Report: Cables Wynd House]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Hood Stones
Robson E (2020) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Hood Stones [Site Report: The Hood Stones]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Dun Carloway Broch, Isle of Lewis
Robson E (2019) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Dun Carloway Broch, Isle of Lewis [Site Report: Dun Carloway Broch, Isle of Lewis]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Arnol Blackhouse, Lewis
Robson E (2019) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: The Arnol Blackhouse, Lewis [Site Report: The Arnol Blackhouse, Lewis]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Research Report
Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Sauchiehall Lane, Glasgow
Robson E (2019) Wrestling with Social Value Case Study Report: Sauchiehall Lane, Glasgow [Site Report: Sauchiehall Lane, Glasgow]. Research co-funded by the University of Stirling and Historic Environment Scotland. Stirling.
Other
Learning from Loss Climate Stories
Graham E, Hambly J, Robson L, Rockman M, Gao Q, Foster S, Miller S & Dawson T (2018) Learning from Loss Climate Stories. [Web]. https://issuu.com/joannahambly/docs/learning_from_loss_climate_stories
Since 2020, I have contributed to Masters-level Heritage courses at the University of Stirling, the University of Aberdeen and Durham University, leading seminars on social value and co-leading student fieldtrips. I have also provided tutoring in research design (3rd year Undergraduate course at University of Stirling) and supervised several Undergraduate and Masters dissertation students (at the University of Stirling and University of Glasgow).