Translating risk: how social workers’ epistemological assumptions shape the way they share knowledge

Citation

Mitchell G & Demir I (2021) Translating risk: how social workers’ epistemological assumptions shape the way they share knowledge. Health, Risk & Society, 23 (1-2), pp. 17-33. https://doi.org/10.1080/13698575.2021.1888892

Abstract
Social workers are at the heart of drives to improve child health and wellbeing, with knowledge sharing between them and other professionals viewed as a way to reduce the uncertainty associated with this area of risk work. We aim to fill a significant gap in the literature by examining how social workers assess, interpret, filter and share knowledge relating to risk and uncertainty – what we call the translation of risk – within their profession. Based on data from a qualitative study with social workers in England between 2012 and 2013, we identify two main approaches social workers employ. We conceptualise them as 1) reluctant translating, and 2) dynamic translating. Our analysis shows that epistemic assumptions such as how social workers conceptualise the fact/value separation; how they view what we call ‘grey evidence’; and how they understand the relationship between objectivity and subjectivity, underpin how social workers translate risk. We add a new dimension to the literature on risk by arguing that we need to pay attention to the epistemological values that underpin ‘client-facing’ risk work. Thus, we aid understanding of not only how knowledge is shared in particular ways, but also why this is the case. We identify reasons why some social workers include valuable ‘grey evidence’ and prioritise adequacy over accuracy in their translations of risk. We highlight, however, that through an over-emphasis on accuracy and boundaries, evidence-based practice might end up driving out ‘grey evidence’ and inadvertently hampering effective decision-making, judgement and knowledge sharing on risk.

Keywords
Risk; uncertainty; social work; evidence; epistemology

Journal
Health, Risk & Society: Volume 23, Issue 1-2

People

Dr Gemma Mitchell

ISMH Hastings Research Fellow, Institute for Social Marketing