Skip header navigation

University of Stirling

×

Article

Conflict in a paediatric hospital: a prospective mixed-method study

Citation
Forbat L, Sayer C, McNamee P, Menson E & Barclay S (2016) Conflict in a paediatric hospital: a prospective mixed-method study. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 101 (1), pp. 23-27. https://doi.org/10.1136/archdischild-2015-308814

Abstract
Background Conflict in healthcare is a well-recognised but under-examined phenomenon. Little is known about the prevalence and causes of conflict across paediatric specialties.  Objective To report the frequency and characteristics of conflict in a paediatric hospital.  Design and setting An explanatory sequential mixed-method approach was adopted. A bespoke questionnaire recorded frequency, severity, cause and staff involved in conflict prospectively. Data were recorded for the same two 12-week periods in 2013 and 2014, in one UK children's teaching hospital. Data were analysed using descriptive statistics and correlation, the findings of which informed the construction of a semistructured interview schedule. Qualitative interviews were conducted with six key informant healthcare professionals to aid data interpretation; interviews were analysed thematically.  Results 136 individual episodes of conflict were reported. The three most common causes were ‘communication breakdown’, ‘disagreements about treatment’ and ‘unrealistic expectations’. Over 448 h of healthcare professional time was taken up by these conflicts; most often staff nurses, consultants, doctors in training and matrons. The mean severity rating was 4.9 out of 10. Qualitative interviews revealed consensus regarding whether conflicts were ranked as low, medium or high severity, and explanations regarding why neurology recorded the highest number of conflicts in the observed period.  Conclusions Conflict is prevalent across paediatric specialties, and particularly in neurology, general paediatrics and neonatology. Considerable staff time is taken in managing conflict, indicating a need to focus resources on supporting staff to resolve conflict, notably managing communication breakdown.

Journal
Archives of Disease in Childhood: Volume 101, Issue 1

StatusPublished
Author(s)Forbat, Liz; Sayer, Charlotte; McNamee, Philip; Menson, Esse; Barclay, Sarah
Publication date01/01/2016
Publication date online09/11/2015
Date accepted by journal09/08/2015
URLhttp://hdl.handle.net/1893/26496
PublisherBMJ Publishing Group Ltd
ISSN0003-9888
Scroll back to the top