Article
Details
Citation
Etone D Counsel in the Dock: Prosecutorial Discretion, Professional Discipline and the Limits of Referral in the Robinson Contempt Proceedings before the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals. International Criminal Law Review.
Abstract
This article offers an original and critical analysis of the Robinson contempt proceedings before the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals. The Robinson Contempt proceedings represent the first occasion on which the Mechanism has itself brought criminal contempt proceedings against defence counsel for conduct in representing a client before it. The article draws on a close reading of the February 2025 charging decision, the Appeals Chamber’s decisions of May 2025 and August 2026, the failed referral to the State Bar of California, and the contempt jurisprudence of the ICTY, ICTR and ICC. On that basis it advances four arguments. First, the Mechanism treats carelessness as capable of amounting to reckless indifference. This departs from the Nobilo standard, sits uneasily with the statutory requirement of knowing and wilful interference, and deepens long-standing concerns about legality. Second, the Single Judge’s proportionality-based sorting of 34 allegations is a real advance in judicial transparency, but it is internally inconsistent. It does not engage with counsel’s good-faith reading of ambiguous protective measures orders, or with the disciplinary regime under the Code of Professional Conduct. Third, Rule 90, as construed on appeal, makes the decision to prosecute counsel effectively unreviewable before trial. Fourth, the referral saga exposes a structural flaw in the residual model. The Statute’s mandatory preference for national referral cannot work where no State has criminal jurisdiction over the conduct, which forces the Mechanism to hold the very trial it was designed to avoid.
The article proposes a principled framework for deciding when to charge counsel, a clarified standard for the mental element, and targeted reforms for the Mechanism's judges and the Security Council. It has significant implications for the independence of the international defence bar, the law of offences against the administration of justice, and the design of residual and future international criminal institutions.
| Status | Submitted |
|---|---|
| ISSN | 1567-536X |
| eISSN | 1571-8123 |
People (1)
Associate Professor, Law