Article

Can a Duty or a Right Be Held Disjunctively?

Details

Citation

Cruft R (2026) Can a Duty or a Right Be Held Disjunctively?. Ratio Juris. https://doi.org/10.1111/raju.70039

Abstract
This paper defends Matthew Kramer's novel proposal that sometimes an individually borne duty can be owed to correlative right-holders disjunctively. It extends the proposal, suggesting that sometimes an individually held right entails correlative duties that are borne disjunctively. Drawing on a suggestion from Zofia Stemplowska, the paper argues that this extension of Kramer's proposal can be developed into a new solution to Onora O'Neill's famous claimability objection to natural human rights to goods and services. The idea is that my human right to subsistence supplies—to take one example—entails preinstitutional correlative duties borne by a disjunction of the agents who could help me secure subsistence.

Journal
Ratio Juris

StatusEarly Online
FundersUniversity of Stirling
Publication date online30/11/2026
Date accepted by journal15/10/2026
PublisherWiley
ISSN0952-1917
eISSN1467-9337

People (1)

Professor Rowan Cruft

Professor Rowan Cruft

Professor, Philosophy

Files (1)