To hire good scientists, look at their peer-reviewing records

Citation

Comerford D (2026) To hire good scientists, look at their peer-reviewing records. Nature, 652, Art. No.: 1420. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-026-01368-0

Abstract
First paragraph: Two of your recent news articles highlight misaligned incentives in the marketplace of ideas. First, hundreds of evaluations of papers submitted to a leading AI conference were copied and pasted from large language models (see Nature 652, 281–282; 2026). Second, a substantial proportion of recent publications in social science failed to replicate (see Nature https://doi.org/q3zf; 2026).

Journal
Nature: Volume 652