Apophasis, agency, and ecstasy: reading mysticism and madness in The Book of Margery Kempe

Citation

McCabe ER (2023) Apophasis, agency, and ecstasy: reading mysticism and madness in The Book of Margery Kempe. Philosophical Psychology, pp. 1-22. https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2023.2215815

Abstract
This paper argues for a reinterpretation of madness and mysticism through an apophatic lens. By using Wouter Kusters' theo-philosophical definition of madness, I argue for a re-evaluation of female mysticism which rethinks ecstatic and ascetic devotion as a form of agency. Focusing on The Book of Margery Kempe, I reconsider theological passion and ground Kempe’s madness within the historical tradition of affective piety, which expresses a desire to join with the humanity of Christ. Within modern readership, there has been an impulse to label Kempe and other mystics with specific psychiatric diagnoses. In resisting this urge, I instead argue for a convergence of madness and mysticism which enables a paradoxical agency through negation of thought and language. This apophatic agency is precisely what imbues female mysticism with the potential for radical, queer social resistance. In extending this discussion to issues of fasting and abstinence, I then consider the role eucharistic devotion plays in enabling women control over the gastronomical and sexual parameters of their bodies. The denial of food and sex becomes integral to Kempe’s mysticism in asserting agency over the psychosexual self. Finally, I end with some reflections on how Kempe’s mysticism might influence contemporary discussions of mental health.

Keywords
Philosophy; Applied Psychology

Journal
Philosophical Psychology

People

Ms Emma McCabe

Tutor, Literature and Languages - Division